Steelbook finishes. The Poor, The Good and the Ugly

ricster

The Fallen Zombie
Premium Supporter
Jul 7, 2012
6,114
Great Britain
Hi. I've been collecting steelbooks for a long long time now and thanks to the help, support and advice picked up from importforums, BR and HDN. I am indefinitely grateful to HDN for the fantastic support of its ninjas and staff and the superb Group Buys. All these guys and girls work effortlessly for us all.

After reading a far load of posts and feedback from the members, its taken me on a trip down memory lane.

(hope you dont mind this thread)

You see a lot of posts from people regarding finishes on steelbooks, people love them, people hate them. As steelbook has picked up popularity you dont but seem to think that the designers just cant be bothered as much any more, and lets just "Bang it out and see if they buy it".

There is still a lot of good steelbooks coming out, but wow, theres a lot of junk as well. Thanks to Wreck explaining we all know about different finishes, matte, gloss, super gloss, zero finish and the new low entry budget smartprice, asda value powdery finish.

Then we get low definition pictures used, like on oblivion steel where you can make out the dots / pixels.
What do you all think about it?????

Take the new Disney/Touchstone range.

IMG_3733.jpg


IMG_3727.jpg


We've seen this finish before with the much talked about Warner "Premium" Collection.

Heres an example of Seven. The UK (powdery finish), Japan (matte finish), Korean (matte finish with metallic cutouts).

Korea is my favourite here.

IMG_3747.jpg

IMG_3748.jpg

IMG_3749.jpg

Looking back at my collection over the years, how have we come to this level of product.

We've seen play's £9.99 price now up to £14.99 on Zavvi with Disney's going for £22.99 at the moment. And with 3D being thrown in, prices are rising to £30 (if you import from Europe).

I've taken a few shots of my favourites. Do you feel its a shame that we dont produce steels like these any more, or are you happy with the finial products we are getting now.

Thanks for reading. Hope i'm now insane. :D

Steels with style and class.

IMG_3739.jpg


IMG_3740.jpg


IMG_3741.jpg


IMG_3742.jpg


IMG_3743.jpg


IMG_3744.jpg


IMG_3745.jpg


IMG_3752.jpg


IMG_3753.jpg


IMG_3755.jpg


IMG_3756.jpg

What is your opinion?

What do you think about the quality of the product currently being churned out in mass?
 
Last edited:
^^^ Jack Reacher is gorgeous...but please tell me that ratings logo is a sticker!!!
EEK!

---------- Post added at 04:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:29 PM ----------

...and ricster, yes, Captain Phillips steelbook is a real mess :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: ricster
Ricster could you take a picture of point blank and try to make it look as good as possible

---------- Post added at 12:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:49 PM ----------

8ynytu8y.jpg


That'd my attempt I've tried improving it by putting it in a box of shredders

---------- Post added at 12:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 PM ----------

Meant point break
 
The Bad and The Ugly list from the top of my head (besides Stickerbook)

1. Pacific Rim Futureshop

2. Point Break UK

3. Warner Premium Collection UK except The Heat and 300 to an extent

4. Blade Runner DE

5. Heat CA

6. Iron Man 3 (front and back not matching, blurry inside artwork, placement of Iron Man image on the inside)

7. Monster's University (Front and Spine)

8. Robocop 1987 Remastered (Way too modern)
 
  • Like
Reactions: howiesteed
Wow, that Kick Ass 2 steel is amazing. I hope I can own that one day!

I haven't been collecting long, but have noticed that a lot of the Warner US steels that I buy are not good quality to say the least.. Like Braveheart and Gladiator. I would rather have another country's steel of these!
 
I've just been looking over my own personal copy of DRIVE (HMV). And I've noticed....is this the only Steelbook ever to have a matte with spot gloss front cover, but a full gloss back cover??

1Mbe0Kz.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: ricster
That's odd . But what I find strange is why do titles have a matte finish front and back yet have a gloss finish inside behind the plastic mermiad dbeing one of these
 
  • Like
Reactions: dfoles
That's odd . But what I find strange is why do titles have a matte finish front and back yet have a gloss finish inside behind the plastic mermiad dbeing one of these

I've noticed that too, like the recent BB Hunger Games. I'm assuming if you had the inside matte, plus the frosted obstruction of the plastic lining, you wouldn't be able to see anything pretty on the inside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ricster
I've just been looking over my own personal copy of DRIVE (HMV). And I've noticed....is this the only Steelbook ever to have a matte with spot gloss front cover, but a full gloss back cover??

The original Capitan America has a gloss front and spot gloss back. I think spot gloss is my favorite finish!