Addt'l Sub-category suggestions for 'Steelbook of the Year 2013'

digitalbabe

Premium Supporter
Apr 12, 2009
42,351
USA
*Mods* please leave here for now, we can move to 'chat' at a later time.

Hello HDN!

For the last few years we have had 1 vote for your favorite 'overall' Steelbook for a certain year.

Several members have suggested we have votes in different categories.

What other categories would you like us to add for different polls this year?

Just chime into the thread and mention why you think the category should be added.

Have fun!
 
Yeah, that's a good idea, categories for animation, sci-fi, horror, drama, & action, also maybe best embossing/debossing, and than obviously best steel.
 
1 overall winner; then maybe a best steelbook/viva/metal/tin, digibook/digipack, slipcover/slipcase (amaray or steel), best memorabilia (must come with a copy of the movie).

If you don't do categories, then maybe list the top vote getters.

I don't want to see otherwise undeserving steels honored because of a lack of competition in their subcategory if you break it down by genre.
 
I'd probably like to see categories whose merit is all about the Steelbook itself

The best 'overall' steel to me is the most complete package steelbook there is. I'd be interested to see categories like best embossing/debossing, best inside artwork, best full slip, best 1/4 slip

Considering how international this little hobby of ours is, might be cool to have categories for best Canadian steel, UK steel, Korean steel etc
 
  • Like
Reactions: bd251
Best Films would be a good one. This year saw a pretty good number of better movies get premuim Steelbook releases especially in the UK apart from the usually excellent Eureka titles. Many of the steelbooks were dissapointing but the titles were very solid one indeed. Examples include
1. Seven Samurai, one of the greatest films ever
2. The Prestige, even if the steelbook looks like an utter failure atleast we saw another very great film get the treatment.
3. The Great Escape, a very highly adored classic
4. Who Framed Roger Rabbit? One of the best films in the Disney Live Action Catalogue
5. Django Unchained, one of last years top films, though not a very special steelbook by any means
6. Argo, the last Best Picture Winner, we are yet to have proper treatments of The Artist and The King's Speech.
7. Pan's Labyrinth, though already released few times its always good to have one more solid title in the bunch
8. Twelve Monkeys, a great surprise.
9. Silence of the Lambs, Edward Scissorhands, X-Men, Robocop, Platoon were poor Steelbooks but very solid titles
10. The Warner Classis wave was riddled with rather disgusting steelbooks but there were huge titles like Treasure of Sierra Madre, Maltese Falcon, Ben Hur, Gone with the Wind, Dr Zhivago, The Jazz Singer. And 2 of the releases North by Northwest and A Streetcar named Desire were rather excellent.
11. Face/Off Finally getting a release it deserves
12. The Sixth Sense, another solid title getting a release
13. Close Encounter of the Third Kind getting a release, albiet one with poor artwork and no second disc.
14. Taxi Driver getting a solid release atlast

So overall there were many badly handled steelbooks but the titles getting the treatments were top class and there was no shortage of real stunners like Who Framed Roger Rabbit, The Great Escape, Argo, Taxi Driver and so on.
 
I'd like to see a more Oscar-y approach with categories like :

- best embossing
- best lenticular
- best exclusive
- best artwork
- best finish
- future grail
 
  • Like
Reactions: harry
Best front artwork
Best back artwork
Best inside artwork

Best use of embossing / debossing
Best SteelBook with lenticular
Highest quality presentation
Best value for money

Best animated feature
Best sci-fi feature
Best horror feature
Best new film release
Best catalogue title release


These can also be reversed to find the worst of each category
 
  • Like
Reactions: harry
Best over package (including slip cases, art cards whatever)
best exterior artwork
best interior artwork
best new release best back catalogue release
worst steelbook
best exclusive
best value
 
Should make an awards show here we could call it "The Steelies"

Have catagory for best inside steelie
Best Asian slip etc
Best sticker
Best back
Best embossed,debossed etc

And Steelie of the year goes to?????