g1 or stickerbook - which do you prefer?

[Wreck]

Just thought it would be interesting to hear people's thoughts on these. I didnt throw in Jumbo's as those seem to be getting more love now-a-days what with people making converts etc.

If your favorite movie didn't get a g2, and it was going to be one of these... which would you prefer?

 

[thedonguillermo79]

G1 all the way for me even though I am looking for some stickerbooks

 

[jbsolo]

G1...although I do have Source Code in the shelf...at least the G1 I can put together with the Games steelbooks...

 

[gummer]

Stickerbook > G1.

The artwork can still look great, and they are the same size as most other Blu-Ray's, compared to the DVD case size of G2's.

 

[Ashcroft]

I could make a stickerbook myself with some glossy paper and some glue, utterly pointless little creations. Scanavo shouldn't even offer them, it cheapens their whole image. Don't mind G1, but G2 is a lot better.

 

[Steelbook PimpSlap]

i prefer G3 Wasssuuupp

 

[MayFlower]

hmmmm...G1 with full printed artwork over G2 stickerbook....

in the end, I'm buying a steelbook with beautiful artwork printed...that's my main goal.

However, a steelbook with no printed artwork inside is just the same as a stickerbook. I would never pay premium or go out of my way for any steelbook with no printed artwork...that's just another half of a stickerbook as well LOL.

---------- Post added at 04:30 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:25 PM ----------

I'm going to help them develop a G3 for the next generation. I'm going to design it with glasss surrounding and a picture inside the glass...like a collecting card..and then on the back..there will be code where you can download the movie....

i prefer G3 Wasssuuupp

 

[blu-steel]

That is like saying would you prefer a cold **** sandwich or a hot **** sandwich.

 

[BluRayJunkie]

While my preference is G1, I have no problem with stickerbooks. G1 have a tendancy to be embossed/debossed quite often.

Why can't I vote using tapatalk? I can't see any polls.

Sent From The Bat Cave.

 

[MayFlower]

what do you want? you can have my vote LOL...I'll vote for you.

While my preference is G1, I have no problem with stickerbooks. G1 have a tendancy to be embossed/debossed quite often.

Why can't I vote using tapatalk? I can't see any polls.

Sent From The Bat Cave.

 

[BluRayJunkie]

what do you want? you can have my vote LOL...I'll vote for you.

Hehe, there is a poll, isn't there?

Sent From The Bat Cave.

 

[stinkofdefeat]

G1 for sure.. I have a about 12 or so G1's and their great, bigger space for pretty artwork. I really don't get why people are so anal about size difference on the shelf, its not that big of a deal.

As for stickerbooks.. I have never owned one.. but they sound horrid.

 

[sundvold]

stickerbook is very cheat. take G1

 

[Lutzo]

Stickerbook! I keep them sealed anyway so I couldn't really tell. I only have Source Code and Inglourous Basterds (FR), but G1 just doesn't work for me AT ALL.
I sold all my DVD steels years ago and only kept Donnie Darko and Donnie Darko/Southland Tales - but only until a BluRay Steelbook comes along for either....

stickerbook is very cheat. take G1

 

[scorpius]

neither

I don't like stickerbooks and I don't like 2 different sized steelbooks in my collection.

 

[DJHilalo]

Neither for me sorry, if I were still collecting DVDs I would take G1 over any G1/G2 stickerbook but thanks god I'm not anymore.

 

[Sigill]

I would take a G1 every time. There are a lot of nice ones out there, Sucker Punch Comic Con is a beauty!

 

[Grapey]

G1 for me - I don't care what size they are (Classy lady!)

 

[Glaurung]

Depends on wether we're talking about a G1 Jumbo and a G2 Sticker, or a G1 Jumbo Sticker and a G2 Sticker, or a G1 Sticker and a G2 Jumbo Sticker, etc....

 

[fariz]

G1 beats sticker anytime.
even though i don't have stickerbook, but i'll choose G1, and i have 1, godfather dvd
eventually, stickers wore out, doesn't it?

 

[digitalbabe]

Yikes, neither...