SteelBook Popularity Game

[Wreck]

Well I suggest to determine the winner, they both start at 0 and the first one to 50 wins? No deducting from the other steelbook, ONLY adding to your preferred choice

Same rules apply of 1 vote per day, etc

Voting will begin in my subsequent post

Read more: https://www.hidefninja.com/community/threads/14761/&page=151#ixzz1yS6c4slX

So ... here is how it works. First and foremost I'm taking off Iron Man FutureShop and John Rambo MM from the list.

Each steelbook starts with 10 points. The object of the game is to eliminate all but one of the steelbooks by bringing their point count to zero. The last steelbook standing is the winner!

The deets:
In your post, add one point to one of thesteelbooks and remove a point from one of the others. Indicate what points you added like so:
+ (insert name here)
- (insert name here)
Update the main list. Copy and paste it into your post, and change the steelbook's point value accordingly. Also, sort the steelbook numerically based on points, in descending order.
If a steelbook's point level reaches zero, that steelbook is eliminated. Add their name to the graveyard (below the main list).

What will be the last steelbook standing!?

I've taken the list from the "rare" thread to make this easy for me. This is for fun, no need to take this too serious. Sorry if your fav title isnt in here. I threw in some titles that werent rare to get some favs in there. You can only POST YOUR CHANGES ONCE PER DAY!!!!

Spoiler

10 - 300 (DE) 1st Release
10 - 1408 (DE)
10 - 10,000 BC (Crackle Laquer, DE)
10 - Angels & Demons (Canada)
10 - Body of Lies w/booklet(FNAC, France)
10 - Book of Eli (CA)
10 - Captain America
10 - Cowboys & Aliens (Target USA Exclusive)
10 - Death Race (Media Markt, DE) (Note: G2 version only)
10 - Der Nebel-'The Mist'(Germany)
10 - District 9 (HMV, UK)
10 - Fight Club (Germany)
10 - Gladiator (TW)
10 - Green Zone (AU)
10 - Green Hornet
10 - Halloween (DE)
10 - Hellboy 2 (Fnac, FR) w/ booklet
10 - Hellboy 2 (MM, DE)
10 - Hurt Locker (BB, US)
10 - I Am Legend (FS, CA)
10 - Inception Briefcase (Fnac, FR)
10 - Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (FS, CA)
10 - Inglourious Basterds (FS, CA)
10 - Iron Man (MM, DE)
10 - Iron Man 2-G1 (Japan)
10 - Le Grand Bleu (Japan)
10 - Let The Bullets Fly (China)
10 - Limitless
10 - Millennium Trilogy-Saturn Exclusive (Germany)
10 - Pan's Labyrinth (Germany)
10 - Predators (Play.com, UK)
10 - Public Enemies (Futureshop, Canada)
10 - Pulp Fiction (FR)
10 - Scott Pilgrim (UK)
10 - Star Trek(Futureshop Exclusive, Canada)
10 - Star Trek (Play.com, UK)
10 - Star Wars Clone Wars (NL)
10 - Sucker Punch (Comic Con Exclusive)-G1 (USA)
10 - Sucker Punch 1st Release (Germany)
10 - Sweeney Todd Play Exclusive (UK)
10 - Terminator 2 (V2, JP)
10 - Terminator Salvation (Taiwan)
10 - The Dark Knight (Fnac, FR)
10 - The Dark Knight-1st Release (Netherlands)
10 - Thor
10 - Transformers Revenge of the Fallen (CA)
10 - Wanted (DE) (Debossed version)
10 - X-Men Origins: Wolverine FNAC Exclusive(France)
10 - Zombieland (DE)

 

[Noodles]

Im good with which ever steel wins at this point except for Sucker Punch. Aldo should be way higher then that skinny girl

I agree. Any of the remaining steels would be a very worthy winner! The only reason I'm voting down IB is because I prefer the Alliance release with the debossed lettering on the gun, over Brad Pitt's derpy face on the FS edition.

91 - Thor
86 - Zombieland
83 - Captain America
80 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
67 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
23 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Captain America
- Inglourious Basterds

 

[MK50]

I prefer the Alliance release with the debossed lettering on the gun, over Brad Pitt's derpy face on the FS edition The same here

91 - Thor
86 - Zombieland
83 - Captain America
81 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
67 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
22 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

- IB
+ Transformers

 

[VRob98]

Im good with which ever steel wins at this point except for Sucker Punch.

I feel the same about Zombieland. Why anybody thinks this:

is better than this:

beats me.

Maybe not many folks open their steels?

 

[xMicheil]

91 - Thor
86 - Zombieland
82 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
67 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
22 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Transformers
- Captain America

 

[Malky78]

91 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
82 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
66 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
22 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Zombieland
- SP

 

[PS3_Kiwi]

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
82 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
66 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
21 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Thor
- IB

 

[Bullet1217]

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
83 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
66 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
20 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
- IB


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Jericho]

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
65 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
20 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
- Sucker Punch

 

[biscuitnoir]

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
21 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)
- Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)

Don't understand... no love for IB FS, beautiful release and kick-ass movie! 10000x better than any other movie in that list

 

[Jericho]

Im good with which ever steel wins at this point except for Sucker Punch. Aldo should be way higher then that skinny girl

Of the remaining ones, I like Sucker Punch and IB the least. IB because Brad Pitt's mug is not all that exciting to me. I love the movie. I know the FS version is rare. But the designs on the other IB Steels are cooler to me and the Brad Pitt shot reminds me too much of the "floating head" syndrome often seen with US movie posters. If it's not even my favorite version of the Steel, I don't want to vote for it.

As for Sucker Punch, it is very nice. But I still like the ComicCon version better (even if its G1). So I knock it down a bit since it's not my favorite Steelbook of that movie.

 

[VRob98]

Don't understand... IB 10000x better than any other movie in that list

Yeah, the movie is. But if we were going on movie, Transformers wouldn't make the top 50! Personally my fave IB issue is the Aussie metal slipcase, while I'm not that crazy about the FS one. Sorry Aldo!

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
65 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
20 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

- Inglorious Basterds
+ Sucker Punch

 

[xMicheil]

Don't understand... no love for IB FS, beautiful release and kick-ass movie! 10000x better than any other movie in that list

Agree with everything you said, people seem to view it as 'Just Brad Pitt' not the totally awesome Lt. Aldo Raine

 

[jbsolo]

Agree with everything you said, people seem to view it as 'Just Brad Pitt' not the totally awesome Lt. Aldo Raine

right now, for me, it comes to how it looks (design), how it feels in your hand (embossed/debossed features), lay-out of pictures...I'm not a blu banner guy so I am going for less words on the cover looks better for me. Inside artwork is a must have also for my vote. And print run is not essential, so even if it's a $300.00 against a $15.00 steelbook, if the "cheaper" one looks better, then I vote that way...

Can someone with ALL of them in their collection post the picture together of all OPEN copies...please...

 

[xMicheil]

right now, for me, it comes to how it looks (design), how it feels in your hand (embossed/debossed features), lay-out of pictures...I'm not a blu banner guy so I am going for less words on the cover looks better for me. Inside artwork is a must have also for my vote. And print run is not essential, so even if it's a $300.00 against a $15.00 steelbook, if the "cheaper" one looks better, then I vote that way...

Can someone with ALL of them in their collection post the picture together of all OPEN copies...please...

I understand what you're saying, for me though when I started collecting & didn't even really know the value of it, IB stood out to me as the best.

My SP is en route but I've got the rest so I took some pics

 

[Jason Bourne]

^^^ I hear what you guys are saying. At end of the day this is a very "subjective" vote. What one thinks is just beauty might look like sh*t to another. With that here's my daily vote:

93 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
82 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
20 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Thor
- Sucker Punch

 

[jbsolo]

93 - Thor
86 - Zombieland
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
83 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
20 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Captain America
- Zombieland

 

[FanOfGaming]

93 - Thor
86 - Zombieland
85 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
83 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
19 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+ Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
- Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

 

[shdl83]

92 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
85 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
83 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
19 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

+zombieland
- thor

 

[dirtyoak]

93 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
85 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
83 - Captain America
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
18 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)


+ Thor
- IB

I too like the embossed IB more than the Aldo one even tho that one is pretty too.
I had never seen the inside of the Sucker Punch before and that changed my mind on it a little bit. Along with IB it has the best looking inside art in my book but I just love the Thor steelbook and as of right now it's the only one I personally own but I'm working on getting most of these. Zombieland is in the mail.

 

[Lucky101]

93 - Thor
87 - Zombieland
84 - Captain America
84 - Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen (FS, CA)
64 - Sucker Punch (1st Release, DE)
18 - Inglorious Basterds (FS, CA)

- Transformers
+ Captain America